Strategist · Ready-to-drink tea · 2023
Sagacity Tea
Arizona sold $650 million of iced tea in a year. Sagacity sold $2.5 million.
TL;DR
For a class case, our 4‑person team played an outside firm hired to grow Sagacity, a $2.5 million tea brand with only 5% of its sales online. I evaluated Sagacity’s current marketing, and 4 of our 5 calls started on my slides. We recommended selling online through ambassadors instead of a broker, the only route of the 3 projected to make money, though the plan was never implemented.
Role
Strategist on a 4-person “outside firm”
Client (case)
Sagacity, a ready-to-drink tea brand
Timeline
Spring 2023, SF State Marketing Management
Status
Academic recommendation, not implemented
3 min read
$2.5M
in annual sales. Arizona sold $650M.
5%
of sales online. The category average is 20%.
3
routes to market, costed end to end
+$155.8K
projected net on the route we recommended
The first 2 are where Sagacity stood. The last is a projection, not a result.
01 The problem
Growth was capped by physical retail
Sagacity sold through 450 retail outlets, but only 5% of sales came from online. It wanted to expand without handing distribution to a broker.
About 300
competitors in ready-to-drink tea
87%
of millennials drank tea
$5M+
to secure premium shelf space in the 50 largest US chains
01
Organic, sugar-free tea from New England
02
PowerMarketing, a top New York broker, offered national chains at a price that was too high
03
Buyers were loyal to Sagacity, and price-sensitive
04
Big brands pay retailers for prime shelf space, which shuts out new entrants
The figures are the case’s own, from 2017.
02 Process
We judged every route on money and effort
4 of us split the case. Matt and Taylor sized the market and the competition. I evaluated Sagacity’s current marketing, from who it targets to how it sells. Then we judged each route by cost and revenue, and by how easy it would be to start.
01
Target markets · health-focused, highly educated millennials, in cities like New York and Philadelphia
02
Positioning · “For tea lovers looking for a flavorful, low-calorie alternative”
03
Product · new varieties and packaging had potential, and the brand was still being built
04
Distribution · 3 part-time salespeople and 1 distributor, with low reach and room to grow
05
Communications · local events and social media, plus a 5-foot bottle in each new town

My slide · Target markets

My slide · Positioning and brand mantra
03 The recommendation
Borrow reach through ambassadors
A 2-tier ambassador program, NYU students first and then niche influencers, tied to trackable discount codes and backed by an online store and an Amazon listing.
The plan: 12 months, with targets and a budget
Lift online share from 5% to the 20% category average and reach $500K in revenue, on a first-year budget of about $148K.
The bet: trusted voices, tracked
Trusted voices reach people more cheaply than ads, as long as every recommendation can be tracked. So each ambassador gets a personal discount code that rewards them and shows Sagacity which voices drive online sales.
04 Routes to market
Only 1 of the 3 routes made money
+$155,784
net · online, direct to consumer (recommended)
−$1,828
net · Shield broker, wholesale
−$91,860
net · regional retail, direct to grocery
Each net is projected revenue minus the cost to run the route, from our 4-person team model in Spring 2023. The plan was never implemented.
The risks we named up front
Selling online could cost Sagacity its exclusive feel, and ads were not cheap: about $1.72 a click on Facebook and $2.32 on Google. We planned for both before we pitched.
05 5 calls in the plan
Each call had a cheaper or flashier alternative
A brokerage deal. Faster shelf space, but less control over brand and margin
No broker: our own online store and Amazon, fed by ambassadors
Across-the-board discounts that would erode the premium image
Value pricing, with discounts only through ambassador codes
A fourth flavor, about $10K to develop before any sign of demand
Stay with the 3 existing teas
Leading with big influencers, who cost more and are less trusted in tight communities
2 NYU student ambassadors first, then 2 larger niche influencers
Google Ads as the lead channel
Social ads on Meta and TikTok, plus SEO for the online store
06 My slides
4 of the 5 calls started on my slides

Call 1: I mapped the channel options before we chose our own channels and ambassadors over a broker.

Call 3: I flagged new flavors as an opportunity. The plan held them until the 3 teas showed demand.

Calls 4 and 5: the mix of events and word of mouth that the ambassador and paid-social choices came from.
07 First-year budget
Where the ~$148K goes
$88,966
Ad promotions
$30,000
Technical support for the online store
$19,250
Logistics
$6,000
Software and website design
$1,901
Influencer royalties
$1,436
Product for ambassadors (68 cases)
Total: $147,552. Ad promotions are 60% of the budget.
08 What I learned
How I worked then, and how I work now
Pitched low-cost, trust-based reach, then put 60% of the budget into paid ads
Make the budget match the thesis, or say plainly why ads are still needed.
Our budget contradicted our thesis
Set 5% → 20% online share without estimating the code redemptions it takes
Model the funnel first, then build the target from the bottom up.
No redemption estimate behind the 20%
Listed 248 cases at a cost that only works for 48
Audit every number before it reaches a client. Small errors like that cost trust.
1 line in our first-year budget
Keep reading · more work 2 of 4
Solo designer · Cinema wayfinding · 2026
Sitin
The movie starts in the dark. So does the search for your seat.
© 2026 Moe Htet
Los Angeles